I have always viewed as circumspect the interest of certain medical specialty societies which take stands that could be viewed by some as political. The need for these groups to make some sort of societal statement applied to medical corollary without the acknowledgement of the majority of its members implies ever so slightly of a kind of elitism better served by organizations more overtly deemed “political”.

Consider the statement by the APA on the recent effects of the oil spill on the incidence of mental illness diagnoses and subsequent insurance claims for treatment.

Mental illnesses brought on by difficult situations surrounding the BP oil spill may be less visible than other injuries, but they are real. An entire way of life has been destroyed, and this is causing anxiety, depression, [PTSD], substance use disorders, thoughts of suicide and other problems,” said APA President Carol A Bernstein, M.D.

The position –  the result of a response to BP’s chief claims administrator essentially denying payment equity with physical ailments payable with the government’s escrow relief funds — sounds more like a pitch to the feds and Big Insurance for more action guaranteeing accessible mental health care under reform. Since the biggest oil fiasco in this country’s history won’t be fading in importance anytime soon, the drive is on for greater awareness of the need for improved access to mental healthcare services.

While there is nothing wrong in actively lobbying the federal government for goals like this — the timing of this announcement, the association with a prominent DC-area mental health lobby, and the strong interest in this particular tragedy (as opposed to other numerous, less newsworthy ones) — should remind healthcare providers of the blurred line between political activism and healthcare advocacy.

Related Posts Within Doctor Pundit:

1. Prominent Healthcare Insurer Lobby Proposes Its Version of Access for All The nation’s largest healthcare insurance lobby & trade group (America’s...
2. Mental Health Patients’ Trust in Public Healthcare Delivery Tested in D.C. Let’s start this post by harkening back to the dawn...
3. Under Reform, New Laws to Increase Access to Mental Health Care Services about to Take Effect It is well known that in the pre-reform era of...
4. Mental Health Services Chain Perpetuated Medicare Fraud Medicare reform as it relates to expenses for mental healthcare...
5. Budget Busting Measures Place Some States at Risk in Delivery of Mental Health Services So-called austerity measures, a strategy in many Republican-dominated state legislatures...